Eisenberg Brilliantly Bedeviled in ‘The Double’
Jesse Eisenberg in THE DOUBLE, a Magnolia Pictures release. ©Magnolia Pictures. CR: Dean Rodgers

Jesse Eisenberg in THE DOUBLE, a Magnolia Pictures release. ©Magnolia Pictures. CR: Dean Rodgers

Front Row Features Film Critic

Director/co-writer Richard Ayoade’s deliciously dark “The Double” is Fyodor Dostoevsky by way of David Fincher’s “Fight Club” and Terry Gilliam’s “Brazil.” Outrageously stylish, frequently unsettling and bitterly amusing, the movie also is a showcase for actor Jesse Eisenberg, who does double duty playing both the invisibly meek office drone Simon James and his aggressively extroverted look-alike James Simon.

Updated to a shadowy and timelessly dystopian proto-computer era, the screenplay by Ayoade and Avi Korine alters enough characters and plot points that it is more “inspired by” than faithful to its source material. The novel’s main character has been transformed from a carriage-riding 19th-century government clerk with a valet to a subway-commuting single-room dweller obsessed with a fellow employee (Mia Wasikowska) who lives within telescope-stalking range. When his double appears as a new hire at the drearily dingy research firm where Simon has put in seven soul-crushing years, no one else seems to notice that the two are identical right down to their matching drab suits.

But while struggling Simon goes unrecognized by even the security guard he sees every morning and is known as Stanley by his belittling boss (Wallace Shawn), outgoing James instantly becomes the firm’s universally popular and quickly promoted golden boy. When fast-talking James offers to give Simon some Cyrano-like assistance with his love life, it’s a given that things won’t end well. How incredibly wrong they go, however, becomes a nightmare of blackmail, violence and overwhelming existential angst.

All of that probably sounds like about as much fun as, well, a Russian novel. What makes the plenty dreadful proceedings so entertaining is the way Ayoade balances Simon’s various miseries with a sense of humor that ranges from absurd to cringeworthy. When Simon briefly removes his suit coat at work, he is sternly admonished by his superior to “put your jacket on, son, this isn’t a brothel.” His company’s TV ad ends with the slogan, “There’s no such thing as special people, just people.” His mother phones a restaurant where Simon is eating to say that she’s disappointed in him and to ask if his date is fertile. And investigators who ask Simon if he’s thinking of killing himself are so dubious when he answers “no” that one says, “Put him down as a maybe.”

Eerie atmospherics include off-camera neighborhood screams and irregular ground rumblings that attract no attention from anyone. A cheesy science fiction series always seems to be on TV. Nothing happens in daylight, not even a funeral, and the Andrew Hewitt ominous-piano-heavy score is interspersed with Japanese pop songs.

Eisenberg is excellent at making both the twitchy pushover Simon and the increasingly intimidating James believable. The visual effects allowing the characters to interact onscreen are convincing enough that they draw no attention to themselves. What’s even more impressive for a non-blockbuster-budget indie like this is the movie’s thoroughly immersive ambiguous-time-period set design, which looks David-Lynch-level disturbing.

The fact that Simon has to lose his identity in order to find out who he is (or to try transforming into someone else) raises interesting points about what defines anyone. When he is told that his work ID has been corrupted, and that he doesn’t exist anymore because he’s “not in the system,” Simon is free to decide whether to disappear or be reborn.

The fact that he should have realized he had this choice all along is a simple moral, but one that resonates nonetheless.